Subversion Repositories svnkaklik

\chap Trial design

The whole design of radioastronomy receiver digitalization unit is constructed to be used in a wide range of applications and tasks related to digitalisation of signal from radioastronomy receivers. A good illustrating problem for its use is a signal digitalisation from multiple antenna arrays. This design will eventually become a part of MLAB Advanced Radio Astronomy System. 

\sec Required parameters

Wide dynamical range and high 3 intercept points are desired. The receiver must accept wide dynamic signals because a typical radioastronomical signal has a form of a weak signal covered by a strong man-made noise.    

\begitems

  * Dynamical range better than 80 dB

  * Phase stability between channels 

  * Noise (all types)

  * Sampling jitter better than 100 metres

\enditems

\sec Sampling frequency

Sampling frequency is limited by the technical constrains in the trial design. This parameter is especially limited by the sampling frequencies of analog-to-digital conversion chips available on the market. Combination of the required parameters -- dynamic range requiring at least 16bit and a minimum sampling frequency of 1 MSPS leads to need of high end ADC chips which does not support such low sampling frequencies at all. Their minimum sampling frequency is 5 MSPS.  

\sec System scalability

For analogue channels scalability, special parameters of ADC modules are required. Ideally, there should be a separate output for each I/Q channel in ADC module. ADC module must also have separate inputs for sampling and data output clocks. These parameters allow for conduction at relatively low digital data rates. As a result, the digital signal can be conducted even through long wires. 

Clock signal will be handled distinctively in our scalable design. Selected ADC chip are guaranteed to have defined clock skew between sampling and data output clock. This allows taking data and frame clocks from the first ADC module only. The rest of the data and frame clocks from other ADC modules can be measured for diagnostic purposes (failure detection, jitter measurement etc.).

This system concept allows for scalability, that is technically limited by a number of differential signals on host side and its computational power.  There is another advantage of scalable data acquisition system -- an economic one. Observatories or end users can make a choice of how much money are they willing to spent on radioastronomy receiver system. This freedom of choice is especially useful for science sites without previous experience in radioastronomy observations.     

\secc Differential signalling 

The concept of scalable design requires relatively long circuit traces between ADC and digital unit which captures the data and performs the computations. The long distance between the digital processing unit and the analog-to-digital conversion unit has an advantage in noise retention typically produced by digital circuits. Those digital circuits, such as FPGA or other flip-flops block and circuit traces, usually work at high frequencies and emit wide-band noise with relatively low power. In such cases any increase in a distance between the noise source and analog signal source increase S/N significantly. However, at the same time a long distance brings problems with the digital signal transmission between ADC and computational unit. This obstacle should be resolved more easily in free-space than on board routing. The high-quality differential signalling shielded cables should be used. This technology has two advantages over PCB signal routing. First, it can use twisted pair of wires for leak inductance suppression in signal path and second, the twisted pair may additionally be shielded by uninterrupted metal foil.              

\secc Phase matching

For multiple antenna radioastronomy projects, system phase stability is a mandatory condition. It allows precise high resolution imaging of objects. 

High phase stability in our scalable design is achieved through centralised frequency generation  and distribution with multi-output LVPECL hubs, that have equiphased outputs for multiple devices. 

This design ensures that all devices have access to the defined phase and known frequency.     

\sec System description

In this section testing system will be described.

\secc Frequency synthesis       

We have used a centralised topology as a basis for frequency synthesis. One precise high-frequency and low-jitter digital oscillator has been used, while other working frequencies have been derived from it by the division of its signal. This central oscillator has a software defined GPS disciplined control loop for frequency stabilisation.\fnote{\url{http://wiki.mlab.cz/doku.php?id=en:gpsdo} SDGPSDO design has been developed in parallel to this diploma thesis as a related project, but it is not explicitly required by the diploma thesis.}

We have used methods of frequency monitoring compensation in order to meet modern requirements on radioastronomy equipment which needs precise frequency and phase stability over a wide scale for effective radioastronomy imaging. 

Every ADC module will be directly connected to CLKHUB02A module which takes sampling clock signal delivered by FPGA from main local oscillator.  This signal should use high quality differential signalling cable -- we should use SATA cable for this purpose. 

\secc Signal cable connectors 

Several widely used and commercially easily accessible differential connectors were considered to be use in our design. 

\begitems

* HDMI % [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hdmi|HDMI]]</del>

* SATA  		%{http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serial_attached_SCSI#Connectors|SAS]]/[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Serial_ATA|SATA]]

* DisplayPort 		%[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Display_port|DisplayPort]]</del>

* SAS/miniSAS

\enditems

At the end, MiniSAS connector was chosen as the best option to be used in connecting together multiple ADC modules. It is compatible with existing SATA cabling systems and aggregates multiple SATA cables to a single connector. It can be seen on the following picture \ref[img-miniSAS-cable]. A transition between SATA and miniSAS is achieved by SAS to SATA adapter cable which is commonly used in servers to connect SAS controller to multiple SATA hard disc in RAID systems and thus is commercially easily available. 

The main drawback of miniSAS PCB connectors lies in the fact, that they are manufactured in SMT versions only. The outer metal housing of connector is designed to be mounted using a standard through-hole mounting scheme, a design that unfortunately decreases the durability of the connector. 

\midinsert

\clabel[img-miniSAS-cable]{Used miniSAS cable}

\picw=10cm \cinspic ./img/miniSAS_SATA_cable.jpg

\caption/f A type of miniSAS cable similar to used.

\endinsert

\secc Signal integrity requirements

We use ADC modules that have DATA clock frequency eight times higher than sampling frequency in single line output mode, implying a 40 MHz output bit rate. 

\secc ADC modules design

The ADC modules have a standard MLAB construction scheme with four mounting holes in corners aligned in defined raster. 

Data serial data outputs of ADC modules should be connected directly to FPGAs for the basic primary signal processing. The ADC chip used in the modules has a selectable bit width of data output bus and thus the output SATA connectors have signals arranged to contain a single bit from every ADC channel.  This creates a signal concept enabling a selection of a proper bus bit-width according to the sampling rate (higher bus bit-width downgrades signalling speed and vice versa.)

In order to connect the above mentioned signalling layout, miniSAS to multiple SATA cable should be used.  

A KiCAD design suite had been chosen for PCB layout. However, the version is, despite having integrated CERN Push \& Shove routing capability, slightly unstable as it sometimes crushes due to an exception during routing. On the basis of these stability issues, the design had to be saved quite often. On the other hand, compared to commercially available solutions, such as MentorGraphics PADS or Cadence Orcad,  the Open-source KiCAD provides an acceptable option and it easily surpasses a widely used Eagle software.

As a part of work on the thesis, new PCB footprints for FMC, SATA a and miniSAS connectors have been designed and were committed to KiCAD github library repository. They are now publicly available on the official KiCAD repository at GitHub.  

\secc ADC selection

There exist several ADC signalling formats currently used in communication with FPGA. 

\begitems

  * DDR LVDS

  * JEDEC 204B

  * JESD204A

  * Paralel LVDS

  * Serdes

  * serial LVDS

\enditems

Because it uses the smallest number of differential pairs, the choice fell on the serial LVDS format. Small number of differential pairs is an important parameter determining the construction complexity and reliability. \url{http://www.ti.com/lit/pdf/snaa110}

An ultrasound AFE chip seems to be ideal for this purpose -- the chip has integrated both front-end amplifiers and filters. It has a drawback though - it is incapable of handling differential input signal and has a relatively low dynamic range (as it consists only of 12bit ADC). Because this IO has many ADC channels the scaling is possible only by a factor of 4 receivers (making 8 analogue channels).

If we require a separate output for every analogue channel and a 16bit depth we find that there are only a few 2-Channel simultaneous sampling ADCs currently existing which meet these requirements.  We have summarised the ADCs in the following table \ref[ADC-type] 

\midinsert \clabel[ADC-types]{Available ADC types}

\ctable{lrrrrrcc}{

\hfil ADC Type & LTC2271 & LTC2190 & LTC2191 & LTC2192 & LTC2193 & LTC2194 & LTC2195 \cr

SNR [dB] & 84.1 & 77 & 77 & 77 & 76.8 & 76.8 & 76.8 \cr

SFDR [dB] & 99 & 90 & 90 & 90 & 90 & 90 & 90 \cr

S/H Bandwidth [MHz] & 200 & \multispan6 550 \cr

Sampling rate [MSPS] & 20 & 25 & 40 & 65 & 80 &  105 & 125 \cr

Configuration & \multispan7 SPI \cr

Package & \multispan7 52-Lead (7mm $×$ 8mm) QFN \cr

}

\caption/t The summary of available ADC types and theirs characteristics. 

\endinsert

All parts in this category are compatible with one board layout. Main differences lay in the sampling frequency and signal to noise ratio, with the slowest having a maximum sampling frequency of 20 MHz. However all of them have a minimal sampling frequency of 5 MSPS and all are configurable over a serial interface (SPI). SPI seems to be a standard interface used in high-end ADC chips made by the largest manufacturers (Analog Devices, Linear technology, Texas instruments, Maxim integrated..). 

\secc ADC modules interface

Both of the ADCdual01A modules were connected to FPGA ML605 board trough FMC2DIFF01A adapter board. The design of this adapter module expects the presence of FMC LPC connector and the board is, at the same time, not compatible with MLAB. It is, on the other hand, designed to meet the VITA 57 standard specifications for boards which support zone 1 and zone 3. 

This industry standard guarantees the compatibility with other FPGA boards that have FMC LPC connectors for Mezzanine Card. Schematic diagram of this adapter board is included in the appendix. 

The primary purpose of the PCB is to enable the connection of ADC modules from space excluded from PC case.  (In PC box analog circuits cannot be realised without using of massive RFI mitigation techniques). 

Differential signalling connectors should be used for conducting digital signal over relatively long cable. Signalintegrity sensitive links (clocks) are equiped by output driver and translator to LVPECL logic for better signal transmission quality.  

\midinsert

\picw=10cm \cinspic ./img/ML605-board.jpg

\caption/f Used FPGA ML605 development board.

\endinsert

Several SATA connectors and two miniSAS connectors are populated on this board.  This set of connectors allows connection of any number of ADC modules in range of 1 to 8. ADC data outputs should be connected to the miniSAS connectors. Other supporting signal should be routed directly to SATA connectors on adapter. 

Signal configuration used in testing construction is described in tables. 

\secc Output data format

\midinsert

\ctable {clllllllll}{

\hfil

 & \multispan9 \hfil 160bit packet \hfil \crl \tskip4pt

Data name &  FRAME  & \multispan2 \hfil ADC1 CH1 \hfil & \multispan2 \hfil ADC1 CH2 \hfil & \multispan2  \hfil ADC2 CH1 \hfil & \multispan2 \hfil ADC2 CH2 \hfil  \cr

Data type & uint32 & int16 & int16 & int16 & int16 & int16 & int16 & int16 & int16 \cr

Content & saw signal & $t1$ &  $t_{1+1}$ &  $t1$ &  $t_{1+1}$ &  $t1$ &  $t_{1+1}$ &  $t1$ &  $t_{1+1}$ \cr

}

\caption/t System device "/dev/xillybus_data2_r" data format

\endinsert

\sec Achieved parameters

\secc Data reading and recording 

For reading data stream from ADC driver Gnuradio software was used. Gnuradio suite consist gnuradio-companion which is a graphical tool for creating signal flow graphs and generating flow-graph source code. This tool was used to create basic RAW data grabber to record and interactive wiev data stream output from ADC modules. 

\midinsert

\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/screenshots/Grabber.grc.png

\caption/f ADC recorder flow graph created in gnuradio-companion.

\endinsert

\midinsert

\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/screenshots/Grabber_running.png

\caption/f User interface window of running ADC grabber.

\endinsert

Interactive graber wiewer user interface shows live osciloscope-like time-value display for all data channels and live time-frequency scrolling display (waterfall wiev) for displaying frequency components of grabbed signal. 

\secc ADC module parameters

Two pieces of ADC module design were realised and tested first piece denoted as ADC1 has LTC21190

ADC chip populated with LT660015 front-end operational apmlifier. This ADC1 module has 1kOhm resistors populated on inputs which gives to module internal attenuation of input signal. Value of this attenuation $A$ is described by formula 

$$

A = {1580 \times R_1 \over R_1 + R_2}

$$

\midinsert

\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/screenshots/ADC1_CH2_FFT.png

\caption/f Sine signal from ADC1 module with LTC21190 and LT6600-5 devices.

\endinsert

ADC1 CH1  maximal input 705.7 mV

\midinsert

\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/screenshots/ADC1_CH2_FFT.png

\caption/f Sine signal from ADC1 module with LTC21190 and LT6600-5 devices.

\endinsert

LTC2271

6600125

1k

ADC2 CH1 maximal input 380 mV

%\chap Example of usage

%\sec Simple polarimeter station

%\sec Basic interferometer station

%\sec Simple passive Doppler radar

\chap Proposed final system

Construction of final system which should be used for real radioastronomy observations will be described. This chapter is mainly theoretical analysis of systems which should be used for data handling. Realisation of these ideas are planed for future development after full evaluation and testing of actual functional example design. 

\sec Custom design of FPGA board

In beginning of the project coustom design of FPGA interface board was supposed. This FPGA board should include PCI express interface and should have lower price than functional example construction. This board should have MLAB compatible design which is backward compatible with existing or improved design of ADC modules. For connection of this board an another adapter board with PCIe host interface was supposed. 

Thunderbolt technology standard was supposed for use in this PC to PCIe -> FPGA module. Thunderbolt chips are currently available on the market for reasonable prices. But specification for these devices are accessible for licensed users only and Intel has mass market oriented licensing policy,   which makes this technology inaccessible for low quantity product design.  In consequence of this external PCI Express cabling and expansion slots should be better solution. 

But this systems and cables are still very expensive. For example (http://www.opalkelly.com/products/xem6110/) has price tag 995 USD at time of writing this thesis.

Therefore better approach must be found.

\sec Parralella board computer

%Parallella is gon

\sec GPU based computational system 

A new GPU development board NVIDIA K1 has been released in recent time it is shown on image \ref[img-NVIDIA-K1]. This board are intended for use in computer vision, robotics, medicine, security, and automotive. This board has ideal parameters for signal processing for this relatively low price 192 USD.  But it is currently in pre-order release stage (in April 2014). 

\midinsert

\clabel[img-NVIDIA-K1]{NVIDIA Jetson TK1 Development Kit}

\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/Jetson_TK1_575px.jpg

\caption/f The NVIDIA Jetson TK1 Development Kit \url{https://developer.nvidia.com/jetson-tk1}.

\endinsert