Subversion Repositories svnkaklik

Rev

Rev 1135 | Rev 1137 | Go to most recent revision | Show entire file | Regard whitespace | Details | Blame | Last modification | View Log

Rev 1135 Rev 1136
Line 228... Line 228...
228
 
228
 
229
% doplnit presny pocet konektoru
229
% doplnit presny pocet konektoru
230
 
230
 
231
Several SATA connectors and two miniSAS connectors are populated on this board.  This set of connectors allows a connection of any number of ADC modules within the range of 1 to 8. ADC data outputs should be connected to the miniSAS connectors, while other supporting signals should be routed directly to SATA connectors on adapter.
231
Several SATA connectors and two miniSAS connectors are populated on this board.  This set of connectors allows a connection of any number of ADC modules within the range of 1 to 8. ADC data outputs should be connected to the miniSAS connectors, while other supporting signals should be routed directly to SATA connectors on adapter.
232
 
232
 
233
Lengths of differential pairs routed on PCB of the module are not matched between the pairs. Length variation of differential pairs is not critical in our design according to facts discussed in paragraph \ref[diff-signaling]. Nevertheless, signals within differential pairs themselves are matched for length. Internal signal trace length matching of differential pairs is mandatory in order to minimize jitter and avoid a dynamic logic hazard conditions on digital signals in worst case. Thus clocks signals are routed in the most precise way on all designed boards.
233
Lengths of differential pairs routed on PCB of the module are not matched between the pairs. Length variation of differential pairs is not critical in our design according to facts discussed in paragraph \ref[diff-signaling]. Nevertheless, signals within differential pairs themselves are matched for length. Internal signal trace length matching of differential pairs is mandatory in order to minimize jitter and avoid a dynamic logic hazard conditions on digital signals, that represents the worst scenario. Thus the clocks' signals are routed in the most precise way on all designed boards.
234
 
234
 
235
Signal configuration used in our trial design is described in the following tables \ref[minisas-interface], \ref[SPI-system] and \ref[clock-interconnections].
235
Signal configuration used in our trial design is described in the following tables \ref[minisas-interface], \ref[SPI-system] and \ref[clock-interconnections].
236
 
236
 
237
 
237
 
238
\midinsert \clabel[minisas-interface]{miniSAS differential pairs connections}
238
\midinsert \clabel[minisas-interface]{miniSAS differential pairs connections}
Line 283... Line 283...
283
\caption/t Clock system interconnections
283
\caption/t Clock system interconnections
284
\endinsert
284
\endinsert
285
 
285
 
286
\secc FPGA function
286
\secc FPGA function
287
 
287
 
288
Several tasks in separate FPGA blocks are performed by FPGA. In first block FPGA prepares sampling clock for ADCdual01A modules by division of main local oscillator. This task is separate block in FPGA and runs asynchronously to other logical circuits. Second block is SPI configuration module, which sends configuration words to ADC modules it is activated by opening of Xillybus interface file. Third block represents the main module, which resolves ADC - PC communication itself it communicates via PCIe, collect data from ADC hardware and creates data packet \ref[xillybus-interface]. Last block is activated after ADC configuration via SPI.
288
Several tasks in separate FPGA blocks are performed by FPGA. In the first block the FPGA prepares a sampling clock for ADCdual01A modules by dividing the signal from the main local oscillator. This task represents a separate block in FPGA and runs asynchronously to other logical circuits. Second block is a SPI configuration module, which sends configuration words to ADC modules and it is activated by opening of Xillybus interface file. Third block represents the main module, which resolves ADC - PC communication itself and it communicates via PCIe, collect data from ADC hardware and creates data packet \ref[xillybus-interface]. Last block is activated after the ADC is configurated via SPI.
289
 
289
 
290
Communication over PCIe is managed by proprietary IP Core and Xillybus driver, which transfers data from FPGA registers to host PC. Data appear in system device file named  "/dev/xillybus_data2_r" on the host computer. Binary data which appear in this file after its opening are described in the table below \ref[xillybus-interface].
290
Communication over PCIe is managed by proprietary IP Core and Xillybus driver, which transfers data from FPGA registers to host PC. Data appear in a system device file named  "/dev/xillybus_data2_r" on the host computer. Binary data which appear in this file after its opening are shown in the table below \ref[xillybus-interface].
291
 
291
 
292
\midinsert
292
\midinsert
293
\def\tabiteml{ }\let\tabitemr=\tabiteml
293
\def\tabiteml{ }\let\tabitemr=\tabiteml
294
\clabel[xillybus-interface]{Grabber binary output format}
294
\clabel[xillybus-interface]{Grabber binary output format}
295
\ctable {lccccccccc}{
295
\ctable {lccccccccc}{
Line 299... Line 299...
299
Content & saw signal & $t1$ &  $t_{1+1}$ &  $t1$ &  $t_{1+1}$ &  $t1$ &  $t_{1+1}$ &  $t1$ &  $t_{1+1}$ \cr
299
Content & saw signal & $t1$ &  $t_{1+1}$ &  $t1$ &  $t_{1+1}$ &  $t1$ &  $t_{1+1}$ &  $t1$ &  $t_{1+1}$ \cr
300
}
300
}
301
\caption/t System device "/dev/xillybus_data2_r" data format
301
\caption/t System device "/dev/xillybus_data2_r" data format
302
\endinsert
302
\endinsert
303
 
303
 
304
Data packet block which is carried on PCI Express is described by table \ref[xillybus-interface]. The data packet consist several 32bit words. First word contain FRAME number and it is filled by saw signal for now, with increment step of every data packet transmission. Following data words contains samples from ADCs for first and second channel. Samples from every channel is transmitted in pairs of two samples. Number of ADC channels is expandable according to number of physically connected channels. An CRC word may be added in future at end of transmission packet for data integrity validation.
304
Data packet block which is carried on PCI Express isa  described in the table \ref[xillybus-interface]. The data packet consist of several 32bit words. The first word contains FRAME number and it is filled with saw signal for now, with incremental step taking place every data packet transmission. The following data words contain samples from ADCs' first and second channel. Samples from every channel are transmitted in pairs of two samples. Number of ADC channels is expandable according to the number of physically connected channels. An CRC word may possibly be added in the future to the end of the transmission packet for data integrity validation.
305
 
305
 
306
FRAME word at beginning of data packet now filled with incrementing and overflowing saw signal is used for ensure that no data samples ale lost during data transfers from FPGA. FRAME signal may be used in future for pairing the ADC samples data packet with another data packet in future. This new additional data packet should carry meta-data information about sample time jitter, current accuracy of local oscillator frequency etc.
306
FRAME word at the beginning of data packet, now filled with incrementing and overflowing saw signal, is used to ensure that no data samples ale lost during the data transfers from FPGA. FRAME signal may be used in the future for pairing the ADC samples' data packet with another data packet. This new additional data packet should carry meta-data information about the sample time jitter, current accuracy of the local oscillator frequency etc.
307
 
307
 
308
Detailed description of currently implemented FPGA functions can be found in separate paper \cite[fpga-middleware]. HDL source codes for FPGA at state which was used are included on enclosed CD. Future development versions are publicly available from MLAB sources repository.
308
Detailed description of the currently implemented FPGA functions can be found in a separate paper \cite[fpga-middleware]. HDL source codes for FPGA at a state in which it was used are included on the enclosed CD. More recent development versions are publicly available from MLAB sources repository.
309
 
309
 
310
% doplnit odkaz na mlab repozitar
310
% doplnit odkaz na mlab repozitar
311
 
311
 
312
\secc Data reading and recording
312
\secc Data reading and recording
313
 
313
 
314
In order to read the data stream from the ADC drive, we use Gnuradio software. Gnuradio suite consists of gnuradio-companion package which is a graphical tool for creating signal-flow graphs and generating Python flow-graph source code. This tool was used to create a basic RAW data grabber to record and interactively view waterfall plots the data streams output from ADC modules.
314
In order to read the data stream from the ADC drive, we use Gnuradio software. Gnuradio suite consists of gnuradio-companion package which is a graphical tool for creating signal-flow graphs and generating Python flow-graph source code. This tool has been used to create a basic RAW data grabber to record and interactively view waterfall plots using the data streams output from ADC modules.
315
 
315
 
316
\midinsert
316
\midinsert
317
\clabel[grabber-flow-graph]{Gnuradio flow graph for signal grabbing}
317
\clabel[grabber-flow-graph]{Gnuradio flow graph for signal grabbing}
318
\picw=\pdfpagewidth \setbox0=\hbox{\inspic ./img/screenshots/Grabber.grc.png }
318
\picw=\pdfpagewidth \setbox0=\hbox{\inspic ./img/screenshots/Grabber.grc.png }
319
\par\nobreak \vskip\wd0 \vskip-\ht0
319
\par\nobreak \vskip\wd0 \vskip-\ht0
Line 324... Line 324...
324
\midinsert
324
\midinsert
325
\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/screenshots/Grabber_running.png
325
\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/screenshots/Grabber_running.png
326
\caption/f User interface window of a running ADC grabber.
326
\caption/f User interface window of a running ADC grabber.
327
\endinsert
327
\endinsert
328
 
328
 
329
The interactive grabber-viewer user interface shows live oscilloscope-like time-value display for all data channels and live time-frequency scrolling display (a waterfall view) for displaying the frequency components of the grabbed signal. Signal is grabbed to file with exactly the same format, as it is described in table \ref[xillybus-interface].
329
The interactive grabber-viewer user interface shows live oscilloscope-like time-value display for all data channels and live time-frequency scrolling display (a waterfall view) for displaying the frequency components of the grabbed signal. Signal is grabbed to file with exactly the same format, as described in the table \ref[xillybus-interface].
330
 
330
 
331
 
331
 
332
\chap Achieved parameters
332
\chap Achieved parameters
333
 
333
 
334
Trial design construction was tested for proper handling of sampling rates in range of 5 MSPS to 15 MSPS it should work above this limit. System works on i7 8 cores computer with Ubuntu 12.04 LTS operating system.  Data recording of input signal is impossible above sampling rates around 7 MSPS due to bottleneck at HDD speed limits, it should be resolved by use of SSD disk drive. But it is not tested in our setup.
334
The trial version construction was tested for proper handling of sampling rates in the range of 5 MSPS to 15 MSPS, but it should work above this limit. System works on i7 8 cores computer with Ubuntu 12.04 LTS operating system.  Data recording of input signal is impossible above the sampling rates around 7 MSPS due to bottleneck at HDD speed limits, but it should be resolved by the use of SSD disk drive. However, such design has not been tested in our setup.
335
 
335
 
336
\sec Measured parameters
336
\sec Measured parameters
337
 
337
 
338
Two prototypes of ADC modules were assembled and tested. The first prototype, labeled ADC1, has LTC2190 ADC chip populated with LT6600-5 front-end operational amplifier. It also has a 1kOhm resistors populated on inputs which give it an ability of an internal attenuation of the input signal. The value of this attenuation $A$ is described by the following formula \ref[ADC1-gain]
338
Two prototypes of ADC modules were assembled and tested. The first prototype, labeled ADC1, has LTC2190 ADC chip populated with LT6600-5 front-end operational amplifier. It also has a 1kOhm resistors populated on inputs which give it an ability of an internal attenuation of the input signal. The value of this attenuation $A$ is calculated by the following formula \ref[ADC1-gain]
339
 
339
 
340
\label[ADC1-gain]
340
\label[ADC1-gain]
341
$$
341
$$
342
A = {806 \cdot R_1 \over R_1 + R_2} \eqmark
342
A = {806 \cdot R_1 \over R_1 + R_2} \eqmark
343
$$
343
$$
344
 
344
 
345
Where the letters stand for:
345
Where the letters stand for the following:
346
\begitems
346
\begitems
347
  * $A$ -  Gain of an input amplifier.
347
  * $A$ -  Gain of an input amplifier.
348
  * $R_1$ - Output impedance of signal source (usually 50 Ohm).
348
  * $R_1$ - Output impedance of signal source (usually 50 Ohm).
349
  * $R_2$ - Value of serial resistors at operational amplifier inputs.
349
  * $R_2$ - Value of serial resistors at operational amplifier inputs.
350
\enditems
350
\enditems
351
 
351
 
352
We have $R_2 = 1000 \Omega$ and $R_1 = 50 \Omega$ which imply that $A = 0.815$. That value of A is further confirmed by the measurement.
352
We have $R_2 = 1000 \Omega$ and $R_1 = 50 \Omega$ which imply that $A = 0.815$. That value of A was further confirmed by the measurement.
353
In our measurement setup we have H1012 Ethernet transformer connected to inputs of ADC. We have used this transformer for signal symetrization from BNC connector at Agilent 33220A signal generator. Circuit diagram of used transformer circuit is shown in picture \ref[balun-circuit]  and circuit realization in photograph \ref[SMA2SATA-nest].
353
In our measurement setup we have H1012 Ethernet transformer connected to inputs of ADC. We have used this transformer for signal symetrization from BNC connector at Agilent 33220A signal generator. Circuit diagram of the used transformer circuit is shown in picture \ref[balun-circuit]  and circuit realization in photograph \ref[SMA2SATA-nest].
354
 
354
 
355
\midinsert
355
\midinsert
356
\clabel[balun-circuit]{Balun transformer circuit}
356
\clabel[balun-circuit]{Balun transformer circuit}
357
\picw=10cm \cinspic ./img/SMA2SATA.pdf
357
\picw=10cm \cinspic ./img/SMA2SATA.pdf
358
\caption/f Simplified balun transformer circuit diagram.
358
\caption/f Simplified balun transformer circuit diagram.
359
\endinsert
359
\endinsert
360
 
360
 
361
The signal generator Agilent 33220A which we used does not have optimal parameters for this type of dynamic range measurement. Signal distortion and spurious levels are only -70 dBc according to Agilent datasheet \cite[33220A-generator]. We have managed to measure an ADC saturation voltage of 705.7 mV (generator output) with this setup, mostly due to an impedance mismatch and uncalibrated measurement setup, with 1V ADC range selected by sense pin. This is a relatively large error, but the main result of our measurement, seen as a FFT plot shown in image \ref[ADC1-FFT], confirms $>$80 dB dynamic range at ADC module input.
361
The signal generator Agilent 33220A which we used, does not have optimal parameters for this type of dynamic range measurement. Signal distortion and spurious levels are only -70 dBc according to Agilent datasheet \cite[33220A-generator]. We have managed to measure an ADC saturation voltage of 705.7 mV (generator output) with this setup, mostly due to an impedance mismatch and uncalibrated measurement setup, with 1V ADC range selected by sense pin. This is a relatively large error, but the main result of our measurement, seen as a FFT plot shown in image \ref[ADC1-FFT], confirms $>$80 dB dynamic range at ADC module input.
362
 
362
 
363
\midinsert
363
\midinsert
364
\clabel[ADC1-FFT]{ADC1 sine test FFT}
364
\clabel[ADC1-FFT]{ADC1 sine test FFT}
365
\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/screenshots/ADC1_CH2_FFT.png
365
\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/screenshots/ADC1_CH2_FFT.png
366
\caption/f Sine signal sampled by ADC1 module with LTC2190 and LT6600-5 devices.
366
\caption/f Sine signal sampled by ADC1 module with LTC2190 and LT6600-5 devices.
367
\endinsert
367
\endinsert
368
 
368
 
369
 
369
 
370
Similar test was performed at ADC2 module. For ADC2 we have to use formula with a different constant \ref[ADC1-gain]. The ADC2 module has LT6600-2.5 amplifiers populated on it with gain equal to $A = 2.457$ and uses the same $R_2$ resistors. We measured saturation voltage of 380 mV (generator output) at channel 1 on this ADC. It is well in parameter tolerances  of used setup.
370
Similar test was performed at ADC2 module. For ADC2 we have to use formula with a different constant \ref[ADC1-gain]. The ADC2 module has LT6600-2.5 amplifiers populated on it with a gain equal to $A = 2.457$ and uses the same $R_2$ resistors. We measured saturation voltage of 380 mV (generator output) at channel 1 on this ADC. It is well within the parameter tolerances of the used setup.
371
 
371
 
372
\label[ADC2-gain]
372
\label[ADC2-gain]
373
$$
373
$$
374
A = {1580 \cdot R_1 \over R_1 + R_2} \eqmark
374
A = {1580 \cdot R_1 \over R_1 + R_2} \eqmark
375
$$
375
$$
376
 
376
 
377
Where the letters stand for:
377
Where the letters stand for the following:
378
\begitems
378
\begitems
379
  * $A$ -  Gain of an input amplifier.
379
  * $A$ -  Gain of an input amplifier.
380
  * $R_1$ - Output impedance of signal source (usually 50 Ohm).
380
  * $R_1$ - Output impedance of signal source (usually 50 Ohm).
381
  * $R_2$ - Value of serial resistors at operational amplifier inputs.
381
  * $R_2$ - Value of serial resistors at operational amplifier inputs.
382
\enditems
382
\enditems
Line 385... Line 385...
385
\clabel[ADC2-FFT]{ADC2 sine test FFT}
385
\clabel[ADC2-FFT]{ADC2 sine test FFT}
386
\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/screenshots/ADC2_CH1_FFT.png
386
\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/screenshots/ADC2_CH1_FFT.png
387
\caption/f Sine signal sampled by ADC2 module with LTC2271 and LT6600-2.5 devices.
387
\caption/f Sine signal sampled by ADC2 module with LTC2271 and LT6600-2.5 devices.
388
\endinsert
388
\endinsert
389
 
389
 
390
Computed FFT spectra for measured signal are shown in the images \ref[ADC2-FFT] and \ref[ADC1-FFT].  Both images confirm that ADCdual01A modules have input dynamical range of 80 dB at least.
390
Computed FFT spectra for measured signal are shown in the images \ref[ADC2-FFT] and \ref[ADC1-FFT].  Both images confirm that ADCdual01A modules have input dynamical range of at least 80 dB.
391
 
391
 
392
\midinsert
392
\midinsert
393
\clabel[SMA2SATA-nest]{Used balun transformer}
393
\clabel[SMA2SATA-nest]{Used balun transformer}
394
\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/SMA2SATA_nest1.JPG
394
\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/SMA2SATA_nest1.JPG
395
\caption/f Balun transformer circuit used for ADC parameters measurement. It is constructed from H1012 transformer salvaged from an old Ethernet card.
395
\caption/f Balun transformer circuit used for ADC parameters measurement. It is constructed from H1012 transformer salvaged from an old Ethernet card.
Line 401... Line 401...
401
 
401
 
402
For additional validation of system characteristics a receiver setup has been constructed.
402
For additional validation of system characteristics a receiver setup has been constructed.
403
 
403
 
404
\secc Basic interferometric station
404
\secc Basic interferometric station
405
 
405
 
406
Interferometry station was chosen to serve as the most basic experimental setup. We connected the new data acquisition system to two SDRX01B receivers. Block schematics of the setup used is shown in image \ref[block-schematic]. Two ground-plane antennae were used and mounted outside the balcony at CTU building at location 50$^\circ$ 4' 36.102'' N,  14$^\circ$ 25' 4.170'' E.
406
Interferometry station was chosen to serve as the most basic experimental setup. We connected the new data acquisition system to two SDRX01B receivers. Block schematics of the setup used is shown in the image \ref[block-schematic]. Two ground-plane antennae were used and mounted outside the balcony at CTU building at location 50$^\circ$ 4' 36.102'' N,  14$^\circ$ 25' 4.170'' E.
407
Antennae were equipped  by LNA01A amplifiers. All coaxial cables have the same length of 5 meters. Antennae were isolated by common mode ferrite bead mounted on cable to minimise the signal coupling between antennas. Evaluation system consists of SDGPSDO local oscillator subsystem used to tune the local oscillator frequency.
407
Antennae were equipped with LNA01A amplifiers. All coaxial cables had the same length of 5 meters. Antennae were isolated by common mode ferrite bead mounted on cable to minimise the signal coupling between antennas. Evaluation system consisted of SDGPSDO local oscillator subsystem used to tune the local oscillator frequency.
408
 
408
 
409
\midinsert
409
\midinsert
410
\clabel[block-schematic]{Receiver block schematic}
410
\clabel[block-schematic]{Receiver block schematic}
411
\picw=\pdfpagewidth \setbox0=\hbox{\inspic ./img/Basic_interferometer.png }
411
\picw=\pdfpagewidth \setbox0=\hbox{\inspic ./img/Basic_interferometer.png }
412
\par\nobreak \vskip\wd0 \vskip-\ht0
412
\par\nobreak \vskip\wd0 \vskip-\ht0
Line 415... Line 415...
415
\endinsert
415
\endinsert
416
 
416
 
417
% doplnit schema skutecne pouziteho systemu
417
% doplnit schema skutecne pouziteho systemu
418
 
418
 
419
Despite of the schematic diagram proposed at beginning of system description....
419
Despite of the schematic diagram proposed at beginning of system description....
420
We used two separate oscillators -- one oscillator drives encode signal to ADCs still through FPGA based divider and other one drives SDRX01B mixer.
420
We have used two separate oscillators -- one oscillator drives encoded signal to ADCs still through FPGA based divider and the other one drives it to SDRX01B mixer.
421
The reason for this modification is a simplification of frequency tuning during the experiment. It is because a single oscillator may be used only with a proper setting of FPGA divider and this divider may be modified only by recompilation of FPGA code and loading/flashing a new FPGA schema. Due to fact that the FPGA is connected to PCI express and kernel drivers with hardware must be reinitialized, reboot of PC is required every time a FPGA scheme is changed.  Instead of this complicated procedure, we set the FPGA divider to a constant division factor of 30 and used another district oscillator for ADCdual01 sampling modules and for SDRX01B receiver.
421
The reason for this modification was an attempt to simplify the frequency tuning during the experiment. A single oscillator may be used only with a proper setting of FPGA divider and this divider may be modified only by recompilation of FPGA code and loading/flashing a new FPGA schema. Due to fact that the FPGA is connected to PCI express and kernel drivers with hardware must be reinitialized, reboot of PC is required every time a FPGA scheme is changed. Instead of this complicated procedure, we set the FPGA divider to a constant division factor of 30 and used another district oscillator for ADCdual01 sampling modules and for SDRX01B receiver.
422
We use ACOUNT02A MLAB instrument for frequency checking of correct setup on both local oscillators.
422
We have used ACOUNT02A MLAB instrument for frequency checking of correct setup on both local oscillators.
423
 
423
 
424
\midinsert
424
\midinsert
425
\clabel[meteor-reflection]{Meteor reflection}
425
\clabel[meteor-reflection]{Meteor reflection}
426
\picw=10cm \cinspic ./img/screenshots/observed_meteor.png
426
\picw=10cm \cinspic ./img/screenshots/observed_meteor.png
427
\caption/f Meteor reflection received by evaluation setup.
427
\caption/f Meteor reflection received by an evaluation setup.
428
\endinsert
428
\endinsert
429
 
429
 
430
\midinsert
430
\midinsert
431
\clabel[phase-difference]{Phase difference}
431
\clabel[phase-difference]{Phase difference}
432
\picw=10cm \cinspic ./img/screenshots/phase_difference.png
432
\picw=10cm \cinspic ./img/screenshots/phase_difference.png
433
\caption/f Demonstration of phase difference between antennae.
433
\caption/f Demonstration of phase difference between antennae.
434
\endinsert
434
\endinsert
435
 
435
 
436
For the simplest demonstration of phase difference between antennae, we have analysed part of the signal by complex conjugate multiplication between channels. Results of this analysis can be seen in the following picture \ref[phase-difference]. Points of the selected part of signal create a clear vector, which illustrates the presence of the phase difference.
436
For the simplest demonstration of phase difference between antennae, we have analysed part of the signal by complex conjugate multiplication between channels. Results of this analysis can be seen in the following picture \ref[phase-difference]. Points of the selected part of the signal create a clear vector, which illustrates the presence of the phase difference.
437
 
437
 
438
 
438
 
439
\secc Simple passive Doppler radar
439
\secc Simple passive Doppler radar
440
 
440
 
441
% doplnit popis
441
% doplnit popis
Line 445... Line 445...
445
 
445
 
446
% doplnit popis
446
% doplnit popis
447
 
447
 
448
\chap Proposition of the final system
448
\chap Proposition of the final system
449
 
449
 
450
The construction of a final system, that is supposed to be employed for real radioastronomy observations will be described in this chapter. It is mainly a theoretical analysis of the data handling systems. Realization of the described ideas might be possible as a part of our future development after we fully evaluate and test the current trial design.
450
The construction of the final system, that is supposed to be employed for real radioastronomy observations will be described in this chapter. It is mainly a theoretical analysis of the data handling systems. Realization of the described ideas might be possible as a part of our future development after we fully evaluate and test the current trial design.
451
 
451
 
452
The system requires proper handling of huge amounts of data and either huge and fast storage capacity is needed for store captured signal data, or enormous computational power is required for online data processing and filtering. Several hardware approach currently exist and are in use for data processing problem handling. Either powerful multi gigahertz CPUs, GPUs, FPGAs, or specially  constructed ASICs are used for this task.
452
The system requires proper handling of huge amounts of data and either huge and fast storage capacity is needed to store the captured signal data, or enormous computational power is required for online data processing and filtering. Several hardware approaches currently exist and are in use for data processing problem handling. Either powerful multi gigahertz CPUs, GPUs, FPGAs, or specially  constructed ASICs are used for this task.
453
 
453
 
454
\sec Custom design of FPGA board
454
\sec Custom design of FPGA board
455
 
455
 
456
In the beginning of the project, a custom design of FPGA interface board had been considered. This FPGA board should include PCI express interface and should sell at lower price than the trial design. It should be compatible with MLAB internal standards  which is further backward compatible with the existing or improved design of ADC modules. For a connection of FPGA board to another adapter board with PCIe we expect a use of a PCIe host interface.
456
In the beginning of the project, a custom design of FPGA interface board had been considered. This FPGA board should include PCI express interface and should sell at lower price than the trial design. It should be compatible with MLAB internal standards  which are further backward compatible with the existing or improved design of ADC modules. For a connection of FPGA board to another adapter board with PCIe we expect a use of a PCIe host interface.
457
Thunderbolt technology standard was expected to be used in this PC to PCIe module which further communicate with MLAB compatible FPGA module. Thunderbolt chips are currently available on the market for reasonable prices \cite[thunderbolt-chips]. However, a problem lies in the accessibility to their specifications, as specification is only available for licensed users and Intel has a mass market oriented licensing policy, that makes this technology inaccessible for low quantity production. As a consequence, an external PCI Express cabling and expansion slots should be considered as a better solution, if we need preserve standard PC as main computational platform.
457
Thunderbolt technology standard was expected to be used in this PC to PCIe module communication which further communicates with MLAB compatible FPGA module. Thunderbolt chips are currently available on the market for reasonable prices \cite[thunderbolt-chips]. However, a problem lies in the accessibility to their specifications, as they are only available for licensed users and Intel has a mass market oriented licensing policy, that makes this technology inaccessible for low quantity production. As a consequence, an external PCI Express cabling and expansion slots should be considered as a better solution, if we need to preserve standard PC as a main computational platform.
458
 
458
 
459
However, these PCI express external systems and cables are still very expensive. Take Opal Kelly XEM6110 \cite[fpga-pcie] as an example, with its price tag reaching 995 USD at time of writing of thesis.
459
However, these PCI express external systems and cables are still very expensive. Take Opal Kelly XEM6110 \cite[fpga-pcie] as an example, with its price tag reaching 995 USD at time of writing the thesis. Therefore, a better solution probably needs to be found.
460
Therefore, a better solution probably needs to be found.
-
 
461
 
460
 
462
An interface problem will by probably resolved by other than Intel ix86 architecture. Many ARM computers have risen on market due to an increased demand of embedded technologies, which require high computation capacity, low power consumption and small size -- especially smartphones. Many of those ARM based systems have interesting parameters of signal processing. These facts make Intel's ix86 architecture unattractive for future projects.
461
An interface problem will by probably resolved by other than Intel ix86 architecture. Many ARM computers have risen on market due to an increased demand of embedded technologies, which require high computation capacity, low power consumption and small size -- especially smartphones. Many of those ARM based systems have interesting parameters of signal processing. These facts make Intel's ix86 architecture unattractive for future projects.
463
 
462
 
464
\sec Parralella board computer
463
\sec Parralella board computer
465
 
464
 
-
 
465
<<<<<<< .mine
-
 
466
Parallella is a new product created by Adapteva, Inc. \cite[parallella-board]. It represents a small supercomputer, that has been in development for almost two years with only testing series of boards produced until now (first single-board computers with 16-core Epiphany chip were shipped in December 2013) \cite[parallella-board]. The board has nearly ideal parameters for signal processing (as it provides around 50 GFLOPS of computational power). It is is equipped with Epiphany coprocessor which has 16 High Performance RISC CPU Cores,  Zynq-7020 FPGA with Dual ARM® Cortex™-A9 MPCore™ and operating frequency of 866 MHz, 1GB RAM, 85K Logic Cells, 10/100/1000 Ethernet and OpenCL support \cite[parallella16-board]. In addition to this, the board consumes only 3 Watts of power if both Zynq and Epiphany cores are running simultaneously.
-
 
467
=======
466
Parallella is a new product created by Adapteva, Inc. \cite[parallella-board]. It represents a small supercomputer, that has been in development for almost two years with only testing series of boards produced until now (first single-board computers with 16-core Epiphany chip were shipped in December 2013) \cite[parallella-board]. The board has nearly ideal parameters for signal processing (as it provides around 50 GFLOPS  of computational power). It is is equipped with Epiphany coprocessor which has 16 High Performance RISC CPU Cores,  Zynq-7020 FPGA with Dual ARM® Cortex™-A9 MPCore™ and operating frequency of 866 MHz, 1GB RAM, 85K Logic Cells, 10/100/1000 Ethernet and OpenCL support \cite[parallella16-board]. In addition to this, the board consumes only 3 Watts of power if both Zynq and Epiphany cores are running simultaniously.
468
Parallella is a new product created by Adapteva, Inc. \cite[parallella-board]. It represents a small supercomputer, that has been in development for almost two years with only testing series of boards produced until now (first single-board computers with 16-core Epiphany chip were shipped in December 2013) \cite[parallella-board]. The board has nearly ideal parameters for signal processing (as it provides around 50 GFLOPS  of computational power). It is is equipped with Epiphany coprocessor which has 16 High Performance RISC CPU Cores,  Zynq-7020 FPGA with Dual ARM® Cortex™-A9 MPCore™ and operating frequency of 866 MHz, 1GB RAM, 85K Logic Cells, 10/100/1000 Ethernet and OpenCL support \cite[parallella16-board]. In addition to this, the board consumes only 3 Watts of power if both Zynq and Epiphany cores are running simultaniously.
-
 
469
>>>>>>> .r1135
467
 
470
 
468
The main disadvantage of Parralella board is its unknown lead time and an absence of SATA interface or other interface suitable for data storage connection. Fast data storage interface would be useful and would allow bulk processing of captured data. Following that, the results of data processing may be sent over the Ethernet interface to data storage server.
471
The main disadvantage of Parralella board is its unknown lead time and an absence of SATA interface or other interface suitable for data storage connection. Fast data storage interface would be useful and would allow bulk processing of captured data. Following that, the results of data processing may be sent over the Ethernet interface to data storage server.
469
 
472
 
470
\midinsert
473
\midinsert
471
\clabel[img-parallella-board]{Parallella board overview}
474
\clabel[img-parallella-board]{Parallella board overview}
472
\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/ParallellaTopView31.png
475
\picw=15cm \cinspic ./img/ParallellaTopView31.png
473
\caption/f Top view on Parallella-16 board \cite[parallella16-board].
476
\caption/f Top view on Parallella-16 board \cite[parallella16-board].
474
\endinsert
477
\endinsert
475
 
478
 
476
If Parallella board will be used as a radioastronomy data interface, there would be a demand for new ADC interface module. The interface module will use four PEC connectors mounted on the bottom of the Parallella board. This daughter module should have MLAB compatible design and should preferably be constructed as separable modules for every Parallella's PEC connectors.
479
If Parallella board will be used as a radioastronomy data interface, there would be a demand for new ADC interface module. The interface module will use four PEC connectors mounted on the bottom of the Parallella board. This daughter module should have MLAB compatible design and should preferably be constructed in the form of separable modules for every Parallella's PEC connector.
477
 
480
 
478
\sec GPU based computational system
481
\sec GPU based computational system
479
 
482
 
480
A new GPU development board NVIDIA K1, shown in the following picture \ref[img-NVIDIA-K1], has recently been released. These boards are intended to be used in fields including computer vision, robotics, medicine, security or automotive industry. They have good parameters for signal processing for a relatively low price of 192 USD.  Unfortunately, they are currently only in pre-order release stage (in April 2014).
483
A new GPU development board NVIDIA K1, shown in the following picture \ref[img-NVIDIA-K1], has recently been released. These boards are intended to be used in fields including computer vision, robotics, medicine, security or automotive industry. They have good parameters for signal processing for a relatively low price of 192 USD.  Unfortunately, they are currently only in pre-order release stage (in April 2014).
481
 
484
 
Line 492... Line 495...
492
\sec Other ARM based computation systems
495
\sec Other ARM based computation systems
493
 
496
 
494
Other embedded ARM based computers, for example ODROID-XU, lack a suitable high speed interface. Their highest speed interface is USB 3.0 which has currently unsettled development support and needs commercial software tools for evaluation and testing.
497
Other embedded ARM based computers, for example ODROID-XU, lack a suitable high speed interface. Their highest speed interface is USB 3.0 which has currently unsettled development support and needs commercial software tools for evaluation and testing.
495
 
498
 
496
 
499
 
497
From the summary analysis mentioned above, the Parrallella board should be a best candidate for computational board in radioastronomy data acquisition system, as it is optimised for high data flow processing. On one hand, Parrallella does not have much memory to cache the processing data but on the other hand it has wide bandwidth data channels instead. Other boards might provide much more computational power -- 300 GFLOPS in case of NVIDIA K1, but they are optimised for heavy computational tasks on limited amount of data which represents a typical problem in computer graphics. However, in our application we do not need such extreme computation power at data acquisition system level.
500
From the summary analysis mentioned above, the Parrallella board seems to be a best candidate for computational board in radioastronomy data acquisition system, as it is optimised for high data flow processing. On one hand, Parrallella does not have much memory to cache the processing data but on the other hand it has wide bandwidth data channels instead. Other boards might provide much more computational power -- 300 GFLOPS in case of NVIDIA K1, but they are optimised for heavy computational tasks on limited amount of data which represents a typical problem in computer graphics. However, in our application we do not need such extreme computation power at data acquisition system level.
498
As a result we should presumably wait until Parallella becomes widely available. Following that, a new ADCdual interface board should be designed and prepared to be used in new scalable radio astronomy data acquisition system. In the meantime, before suitable computing hardware become accessible, the required applications and algorithms should be optimised using the proposed trial design.  with FPGA development board on standard PC host computer with PCI Express interface to development board.
501
As a result we should presumably wait until Parallella becomes widely available. Following that, a new ADCdual interface board should be designed and prepared to be used in new scalable radio astronomy data acquisition system. In the meantime, before suitable computing hardware become accessible, the required applications and algorithms should be optimised using the proposed trial version with FPGA development board on standard PC host computer (having a PCI Express interface to development board).
499
 
502